May
the 4th Be With You!
For “May the 4th” I had fans rank their favorite Star Wars films
and the results are fascinating.
If
there is anything “The Last Jedi” taught us it is this: Star Wars films can be
polarizing. Critics and fans alike hailed “The Last Jedi" as the best film since
“The Empire Strikes Back”, while others claimed that “The Last Jedi” was an
attack on fandom and that Rian Johnson was a War Criminal. That’s the narrative
anyway. But was “The Last Jedi” really the most polarizing Star Wars film? The
beauty of polls is that you can cut through the noise and examine raw data.
What do fans really think?
While
polling 100 Star Wars fans I was interested in the question of polarization.
What made one fan cringe at something another fan loved? Did it come down to
age? Gender? Taste? What were the best films? The best characters? Books? There
is a lot I want to break down over the next three days. But first let’s get
back to “The Last Jedi”. Is it good or not?
The
raw data does seem to suggest that the film is (at least currently) the most
polarizing Star Wars film. 19% of respondents ranked the film as the worst Star
Wars film where 12% said it was the best. Another 25% places the film squarely
in the center at number 5. But overall the film seems to be enjoyed among
fandom. It ranked the highest of any film since “Return of the Jedi”.
It
was no surprise to me that the classic films were ranked highest by most Star
Wars fans. 46% of fans agree that “The Empire Strikes Back” is the best film in
the franchise, while 26% of fans agree that the original “Star Wars” is the
second best film, and 25% of fans agree that “Return of the Jedi” is the third
best film.
Fans
also seem to generally agree that the prequels are not as good. 37% of fans
maintain that “The Phantom Menace” is the worst Star Wars film, where 41% agree
that “Attack of the Clones” is the second worst, and 35% agree “Revenge of the
Sith” is the third worst.
Then
we have the new Disney films falling somewhere in the middle with fans enjoying
“The Force Awakens” and “Rogue One” about equally and “The Last Jedi” a little
more.
But
where opinions differ (and they do differ) what conclusions can we draw? Are
there patterns to be found?
The
first generation I wanted to isolate were very, very young fans, let’s say
teenagers. They would have been born after the release of The Phantom Menace
and perhaps the first Star Wars film they saw in cinemas would have been “The
Force Awakens”. Free of classic trilogy bias, free of fan entitlement, What
would they think?
Turns out younger fans aren’t so different from older fans. Fans ages 7-16
agree that “The Empire Strikes Back” is the best Star Wars film and that the
Classic Trilogy is generally better than anything else. The biggest surprise is
that younger fans ranked “Rogue One” as being their least favorite film, with
many of them ranking “Rogue One” as the 8th or 9th best
film in the franchise. “Rogue One” is arguably the darkest Star Wars film and
probably least resembles the animated Star Wars TV shows that this generation
has grown up with.
Younger
fans also seem to disproportionally love “Revenge of the Sith”. Most fans under
30 rank ROTS higher than “The Force Awakens” and “Rogue One”. When we look at
fans over the age of 30, “Revenge of the Sith” drops dramatically in
popularity. Yet all ages of fans tend to agree that it is still the best of the
prequel trilogy.
An
interesting fact about fans ages 20-24 is that they love “The Last Jedi” more
than anyone. In fact, they are the only age group of fans to love it more than
any of the classic films. So many fans in this age group found TLJ to be the
best “Star Wars” film. This age group would have been teens during the later
seasons of “The Clone Wars” TV show, which focused on a lot of Force mythology.
Perhaps this is what they enjoy about “The Last Jedi”. Or maybe it’s the
fathiers, who can say?
Even
though all ages of fans find that the classic trilogy has the best films,
Middle-aged fans seem to be the most passionate about these first films in the
saga. There does seem to be a phenomenon that older fans are less enthusiastic
about “Return of the Jedi”. In fact, fans over 50 seem to enjoy the new Disney
films a lot more than ROTJ and fans in their 40s also tend to think that ROTJ
just isn’t up to snuff compared to ANH or ESB. This is probably because young
fans growing up with Star Wars in the 70s started to age out of the franchise just as it
was introducing Ewoks into the films. The Ewok backlash didn’t affect my
generation (fans in their 30s) as much because we first saw ROTJ at a very young age and for us it
has always been part of the franchise. Some of us would have even seen the Ewok TV films before the Original Trilogy. But I can see how fans a decade or two
older than me would resent the furry little creatures.
It’s
also worth noting that fans over 50 ranked “A New Hope” in a virtually tie with
“The Empire Strikes Back” as best film in the franchise, while fans under 40
find “Empire” to be superior. I guess it shouldn’t be a surprise that the over
40 crowd (who may actually remember seeing “A New Hope” in cinemas) would have
a soft spot for the first Star Wars film in their hearts.
The
data collected here is only a very thin slice of the fandom population, but I
am very happy that I was able to collect data from fans as young as 7 and as
old as 77. There are some notable trends. My analysis of these trends is only
conjecture, so you can come up with your own theories.
Tomorrow,
I will be back on Cinco de Mayo with some more data and graphs. This time I
will examine fandom’s favorite characters. Until then “May the 4th
be with you!
May the 4th Specials
2020 - 40 Ways to Strike Back
https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2020/05/40-ways-to-strike-back.html
2019 - 151 Star Wars Aliens
https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2019/05/151-aliens-how-many-do-you-know.html
2018 - Star Wars Polls
Movie Polls -https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2018/05/star-wars-polls.html
Character Polls - https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2018/05/more-polls-characters.html
Expanded Universe Polls- https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2018/05/the-polls-that-define-us.html
2017 - 40 Years of Fandom https://roadto7.blogspot.com/2017/05/40-years-of-fandom.html
2015 -Genre-Bending the Original Trilogy
Samurai New Hope- http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2015/05/a-new-hope-as-samurai-film.html
Western Empire Strikes Back - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2015/05/the-empire-strikes-west.html
Pirate Return of the Jedi - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2015/05/return-of-jedi-as-pirate-film.html
2014 - Recasting Star Wars
Prequel Trilogy 70s Casting - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2014/05/recasting-trilogy.html
Original Trilogy 90s Casting - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2014/05/recasting-star-wars-original-trilogy.html
Sequel Trilogy Casting- http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2014/05/recasting-trilogy.html
2013 - The Prequels Rewritten: A Fanfic
Episode I - The Saga Begins - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2013/05/may-fourth-trilogy-re-written.html
Episode II - The Clone War - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2013/05/may-mayo-be-with-you-episode-ii.html
Episode III - Rise of the Sith - http://roadto7.blogspot.com/2013/05/episode-iii-remake-rise-of-sith.html
You made us vote on characters as well were are those results
ReplyDeleteThey are coming tomorrow! :)
DeleteHah! It's a beautiful sight to see all those fans saying "TLJ is the best Star Wars move ever!" get their asses handed to them by pure unbridled RESULTS.
ReplyDeleteare you not seeing the same results that i am? no one says its the best ever, but it certainly seems to be very popular, despite people thinking it was the worst
Delete